Manchester United 3-1 Tottenham Hotspur | Premier League match report

Sir Alex Ferguson can rarely have been happier to do Manchester City a favour. In denting Tottenham Hotspur’s Champions League ambitions, Manchester United’s manager saw his side not only clamber back above Chelsea at the top of the Premier League but pile immense psychological pressure on Carlo Ancelotti’s team.

United’s ascendancy may be strictly temporary – the Londoners could reclaim top spot tomorrow – but, despite the surprise absence of Wayne Rooney, they made it plain the title is firmly back within their sights.

Harry Redknapp, the subject of lavish pre-match praise from Ferguson, had bravely configured his Spurs in a 4-4-2 system and, for a while, they threatened to at least hold their hosts to a draw but, after a slow burn beginning, United were ultimately too strong for them.

The first half proved deceptively anti-climatic. Its slightly underwhelming quality could arguably be attributed to the huge amount of effort both teams, and Tottenham especially, were expending in tracking back, closing each other down and winning tackles.

The downside of such often manic industry was that, with one or two notable exceptions – step forward Luka Modric – players seemed too mentally tired to conjure defence-bisecting final passes. If imagination was lacking so, too, was the ability to keep the ball for long.

Tottenham’s Tom Huddlestone was a serial culprit and the resultant pressure on his team-mates to defend from the front frequently saw Jermain Defoe forced deep in midfield – and even winning challenges – rather than menacing Jonny Evans and company in the penalty area.

It speaks volumes that one of the half’s biggest cheers was reserved for Owen Hargreaves, back on the bench after being sidelined for 580 days with severe knee trouble, when the United midfielder indulged in a touchline warm-up routine.

Shortly afterwards, on the half hour mark, Old Trafford witnessed the afternoon’s first shot – a weak Roman Pavlyuchenko effort directed straight at Edwin Van der Sar.

United’s best early chance arrived when Dimitar Berbatov, playing against his old club, did well to control Rafael’s slightly overhit pass along the edge of the area before striking a shot just over Heurelho Gomes’s bar. Otherwise, the best Ferguson’s team could muster was an Antonio Valencia strike dispatched at the perfect height for Gomes to gather. The most significant thing about it was probably that, for once, Valencia had not been out-paced by Gareth Bale, Tottenham’s speedy left-back.

United’s manager had devoted part of his programme notes to an ode to Modric – a perhaps not so subtle message to the Croatian that, should he tire of London, a new home at Old Trafford could very well await.

It was not Modric’s fault that his team-mates did not always read his clever passes and many of his good ideas went to waste. Ferguson, though, will surely have noted the moment when he sold Paul Scholes a dummy. Modric might just make an ideal long-term replacement for Scholes.

The second half began with Patrice Evra being sick on the pitch but the Frenchman, later replaced by John O’Shea, recovered sufficiently to sling in an elusive cross that prefaced Berbatov very nearly scoring with a header.

If United has spent much of the first period shadow-boxing, the brooding presence of Ferguson in the technical area in his summer suit reminded them that they desperately needed to start landing some telling blows.

Ferguson ventured a rare smile when Benoît Assou-Ekotto’s trip on Patrice Evra following Berbatov’s clever pass won his side a penalty. It grew considerably broader when, despite Gomes’s diving the right way, Ryan Giggs squeezed his kick into the corner.

The equaliser originated from another dead ball and featured Ledley King out-jumping Michael Carrick – newly on as a substitute – to connect with Bales’s corner and power the ball past Van der Sar.

Federico Macheda, United’s young Italian striker, has not made the progress expected of him this season but, very shortly after replacing Rafael, Macheda created his side’s second goal. Accelerating on to his astute short pass, Nani advanced before lifting the ball over Gomes.

As Spurs drove forward in search of a way back into the game, United made the most of the defensive gaps they left behind. Accordingly when a frantically backpedalling Wilson Palacios shoved Nani over, a second penalty was awarded.

Giggs stepped forward once more and, although Gomes again guessed the direction of his kick, its execution proved far too good for him.

Premier LeagueManchester UnitedTottenham HotspurLouise Taylorguardian.co.uk

Manchester United v Tottenham Hotspur

Our man at Old Trafford, Tom Jenkins, captures all the action as the battle for both the title and fourth place hots up

Tom Jenkins

Tottenham and Manchester United have a history of exciting encounters | David Lacey

The two sides, who meet tomorrow at Old Trafford, have a long tradition of open‑ended, fluctuating and imaginative games

Tomorrow’s game between Manchester United and Tottenham at Old Trafford is heavy with significance. United’s hopes of winning a historic fourth successive league title have been revived by Chelsea’s attack of hiccups while Spurs’ chances of holding on to fourth place were not harmed by Manchester City’s defeat last Saturday in the derby. Whatever happens the outcome will have a considerable influence on who finishes where at the top of the Premier League.

Yet for most of the 75,000-odd fans making their way to Old Trafford tomorrow lunchtime the sense of anticipation will have been sweetened not so much by the consequences of the result as the likely quality of the entertainment involved in producing it. City against United was all about who won and lost; the game was largely a humdrum affair only partly redeemed by Paul Scholes’s melodramatic late winner. By contrast matches between United and Spurs have a tradition of producing open‑ended, fluctuating encounters in which attacking imagination and individual ingenuity has frequently upstaged grim defence and the desire to stop people playing.

When Harry Redknapp’s Tottenham side get it together they begin to stir memories of things past: Gareth Bale regularly turning defences on the left before cutting in towards goal with the speed and audacity of another Welshman, Cliff Jones; Luka Modric opening up a path to goal with the subtleness of touch of another John White; and, not least, Heurelho Gomes bringing the speed of reflex and gymnastic flair to his goalkeeping that used to distinguish the saves of Bill Brown.

Sir Alex Ferguson’s Manchester United are essentially a team in transition, striving to preserve a balance between such relative newcomers as Darren Fletcher, Patrice Evra, Jonny Evans and the Da Silvas, Rafael and Fabio, while asking for a few more miles from Scholes, Ryan Giggs and Gary Neville. They have become over‑dependent on Wayne Rooney this season and fears of what might happen should he be injured may yet be borne out. Either way this is not the moment to discuss the present United side in terms of George Best, Denis Law and Bobby Charlton, not to mention Eric Cantona, Mark Hughes and Roy Keane or, if it comes to that, Dwight Yorke and Andy Cole.

Even so, and whatever team Ferguson fields tomorrow, United can still play with the speed and verve that takes them from deep defence to all-out attack in the blinking of an eye and it is this, combined with Spurs’ ability to catch opponents on the break, which promises a game to brighten the end of a non-vintage season. A home victory is likely with a draw not impossible. Tottenham could win, but probably not quite so emphatically as they did in the autumn of 1959 when most of those who would complete the Double the following season stunned Old Trafford by beating Matt Busby’s United 5-1.

Spurs, captained by Danny Blanchflower, were in the middle of the 12-match unbeaten run with which they started that season, a run that included 5-1 victories against Newcastle, Preston and Wolves. United were still recovering from Munich and three seasons later found themselves in a relegation struggle not helped by a further thrashing at White Hart Lane, where they lost 6-2.

One encounter between the teams in the early 60s is remembered for a less happy reason. Tottenham, who had won the Cup-Winners’ Cup the previous season, were drawn against United, the FA Cup holders, in the 1963-64 tournament and seemed set to go through after goals from Dave Mackay and Terry Dyson had brought them a 2-0 victory in the home leg. The return match had been going eight minutes when Mackay went into a tackle with Noel Cantwell and suffered a double fracture of his left leg. In those days there were no substitutes and United beat Spurs’ 10 men 4-1.

In more recent times two games stand out, the 2-1 win over Spurs in 1999 that enabled Ferguson’s side to regain the Premier League title from Arsenal (the first part of the treble) and the extraordinary affair at White Hart Lane in September 2001 when Glenn Hoddle’s Tottenham led 3-0 at half-time only to lose 5-3, a result described by the United manager as the best away win of his career at Old Trafford.

Some Spurs fans may consider that selling the strolling Dimitar Berbatov to Fergie for £30m was belated revenge. Others will recall that Tottenham also sold United Teddy Sheringham, who proved a more-than-adequate replacement for Cantona.

Tottenham HotspurManchester UnitedPremier LeagueDavid Laceyguardian.co.uk