Arsenal expose Spurs’ defence and Keane’s pre-match bravado | Dominic Fifield

Despite Robbie Keane’s brave talk, Tottenham’s shambolic defending suggested they are a long way behind the big four

Suddenly, Robbie Keane’s bold claim that Tottenham Hotspur are “definitely on a par” with Arsenal seems rather misguided. A gut-wrenching 30-second period just before half-time, in which the hosts ignited and Spurs imploded, choked those aspirations and rendered the visitors a team shell shocked. Their game of catch-up thereafter always felt forlorn.

If Tottenham are vastly improved from the side that arrived here last term bottom of the table to pluck a staggering 4-4 draw from a helter-skelter derby, then certain flaws still clearly remain. Any argument that they had arrived here depleted by injury and suspension was countered by the reality that for 42 minutes they stifled the hosts’ midfield and induced sloppiness that had the home partisans chuntering up the aisles towards their half-time pies.

Then, mystifyingly, Spurs simply switched off as if their jobs were done. Ledley King may have appeared most culpable as Robin van Persie stabbed Bacary Sagna’s centre through Heurelho Gomes’ grasp at the near-post, the centre-half caught flat-footed as the Dutchman ghosted in on the inside, but why had Benoit Assou-Ekotto and Robbie Keane permitted Sagna and Cesc Fàbregas time at the key throw-in seconds earlier for the Frenchman to eke out the space to conjure the cross? Where, too, was Sebastien Bassong as the ball looped in on his side towards the near-post?

That inquest was still on-going, of course, when Spurs re-started the game, Wilson Palacios carelessly surrendering possession, via Van Persie’s touch, to Fabregas and then melting along with Tom Huddlestone and King as the Spaniard sprinted through the centre to side-foot a second beyond the exposed Gomes. The shambolic nature of the concession was hard to grasp, though this was rapidly turning into one of those tormented Tottenham days.

Panic had long since set in. The third on the hour-mark confirmed as much. Assou-Ekotto’s foul on Fabregas prompted players on both sides to stop with Mark Clattenburg bellowing to play on. Sagna did just that though, even so, his low centre should have been collected by either Gomes or King only for fragility to flare again. Amid the creaking limbs and muddled minds in the centre, the ball dribbled cruelly through goalkeeper and centre-half for Van Persie to tap in.

Doubts will be raised now, surely, over whether King can be expected to excel in games of this magnitude with little to no training behind him given his chronic knee problems. Yet he was not alone in being error-prone and ponderous here while Jonathan Woodgate and Michael Dawson – “themselves hampered by recent injuries” – watched on from the bench.

Spurs have now lost to Manchester United, Chelsea and Arsenal this season, conceding three times to each having been exposed ruthlessly as a work in progress at the back. Their victory over Liverpool on the opening day, which hinted at an imminent challenge to the top four, is starting to look like the exception that proves the rule. This side, on this display, does not appear ready.

Premier LeagueArsenalTottenham HotspurDominic Fifieldguardian.co.uk

Carling Cup: Tottenham Hotspur 2‑0 Everton

Everton are supposed to enjoy themselves at White Hart Lane. David Moyes’s team had won on each of their previous three visits but here, in keeping with their miserable recent form, they found themselves unable to force the break that might have energised their season while, at the back, they continued to resemble an accident waiting to happen.

Everton worked the Tottenham goalkeeper Heurelho Gomes and they departed with other regrets, chief among them the concession of the penalty that Robbie Keane tucked away at the second attempt for Tottenham’s clinching goal. They cannot have been too thrilled, either, at the manner in which Tom Huddlestone was allowed to saunter onto the end of a quick break to rattle home the first.

Tottenham, however, were value for the victory, which carried them into the quarter-finals of the Carling Cup. With Huddlestone imperious and David Bentley putting his troubles behind him to show the touch and commitment of old, their fans could smile once more after Saturday’s shock home loss to Stoke City. Momentum is back with them.

The evening was particularly satisfying for Bentley, whose off-the-field problems have been well-documented. It is almost a year to the day since he scored his 45-yard lob at the Emirates Stadium against his former club Arsenal, in the 4-4 draw, but his career has veered off the rails.

With Aaron Lennon ruled out of Saturday’s derby at Arsenal with ankle damage, Bentley has surely earned his place in Harry Redknapp’s team.

“It’s been difficult since I’ve been here at Spurs, I’ve encountered every problem in the book,” Bentley said. “Sometimes, my efforts have been lacking at times because I haven’t been fully focused on football but I think I’ve got that right now. It was the best thing ever to come to Tottenham and score that goal at Arsenal. Hopefully, it can happen again.”

Everton had set up to take the game to Tottenham; their line-up bristled with attack-minded players and the first chance of the evening fell to them. Louis Saha took a touch and hooked speculatively for goal, on the volley and over his shoulder, but Gomes, back-pedalling, produced an acrobatic save.

Gomes, as ever, mixed the sublime with the ridiculous. Plenty of his distribution had to be filed under “Horror show”. Against that, however, were his saves, the pick of which came from the substitute Jô, when he got down at full stretch early in the second half.

Tottenham took control of the first-half and they might have led before Huddlestone’s goal had Roman Pavlyuchenko not looked so jittery. While Bentley excelled, Redknapp’s other high-profile recall flopped. Twice in the first-half, he snatched at presentable chances, the first after he had raced through on goal. Sylvain Distin was in close proximity on each occasion.

It was excruciating for David Moyes that Huddlestone’s goal should come on the break, after Tottenham had repelled an Everton set piece. Moments earlier, Keane had hit the post following an embarrassing miskick by Distin but this time, Keane’s role was that of creator. He led Tottenham forward and floated an inviting pass out wide to Bentley, who whipped over his cross. It eluded Keane and Pavlyuchenko but Huddlestone, arriving on the far side, thumped an emphatic left-footed drive past Tim Howard.

Everton pressed after the interval and first Tim Cahill and then Jô brought reflex saves out of Gomes. Tottenham, though, knew it was going to be their night, with the manner of their second goal. Keane went down over Distin’s clumsy challenge but he sent his penalty kick too close to Howard, who pushed it out before blocking the rebound bravely at Bentley’s feet. Cue an unholy scramble in which the ball ricocheted implausibly back to Keane, who lashed high into the net. Keane’s celebrations consisting of him repeatedly crossing himself.

Gomes made further saves from Marouane Fellaini and a back header from his own defender Alan Hutton, and Moyes headed back to Merseyside cursing the injustice of having been forced to play a third away match in the space of six days. His request to the Football League to move the tie fell on deaf ears and, to illustrate his unhappiness, he refused to conduct any post-match interviews. The stage was left for Redknapp.

“I’ll keep playing a team that can get us to Wembley,” he said, as he hoped that Tottenham could reach the final of this competition for the third year in a row. “We’ll go for it.”

Carling CupTottenham HotspurEvertonDavid Hytnerguardian.co.uk