Fulham 0-0 Tottenham Hotspur | FA Cup sixth round match report

Fulham have become such a power at home this season that on the face of it Tottenham should be grateful for a second chance in their FA Cup quarter-final following Saturday’s scoreless encounter at Craven Cottage. Harry Redknapp, the Spurs manager, implied as much after the game but had the quality of his team’s finishing matched the slickness of their build-ups they might already be in the last four instead of facing a replay which could clog up their aim of finishing in the Premier League’s first four.

If the performance proved anything it was that while Peter Crouch and Roman Pavlyuchenko might be in excellent form individually they are not yet an item as an attacking partnership. The predatory instincts of Jermain Defoe, whose contribution was restricted by a hamstring problem to the last nine minutes, were badly missed as the Anglo-Russian pair struggled to maintain a tenuous link near goal. “We kept possession well enough although we didn’t create enough chances,” Redknapp admitted.

Yet the opportunity to create chances was always there and often stemmed from Gareth Bale’s consistency in outwitting Fulham’s defence on the left. The young Welshman has rarely played better. Normally he advances from left-back but here he was used as a wide man in midfield, which meant that the threat to Fulham was more immediate and occurred more often.

The frequency with which Bale reached the byline and switched the ball into the goalmouth with crosses which were more like rifle shots – and in sharp contrast to Vedran Corluka’s blunderbuss on the other flank – should have enabled Tottenham to achieve more scoring attempts than they did. And too many of those were off target.

In the end Spurs’ Brazilian goalkeeper Heurelho Gomes had a busier evening than Fulham’s Mark Schwarzer, particularly at the start of the second half when Roy Hodgson’s players managed to up their previously pedestrian tempo and get more people forward to support Bobby Zamora.

Gomes made a series of sharp saves, the best to keep out a goal-bound header from Zoltan Gera, and reaffirmed his status as a Premier League goalkeeper of genuine class. When he first arrived at White Hart Lane from PSV Eindhoven, Gomes appeared set on supporting the theory that in Brazil as in the playground the worst player goes in goal.

Redknapp’s first defeat in charge of Tottenham was the consequence of a howler by Gomes at Fulham in November last season. Yet the goalkeeper had established a reliable reputation at PSV so maybe it was just a matter of getting used to being bombarded from on high in the English game.

Either way, Redknapp was pleased his first impressions had not been borne out. “Gomes looked different to the goalkeeper who came here in 2008 when I first arrived,” he said. “He had a terrible time here but he’s a different lad now; full of confidence who looks what he is, a top keeper.”

For Fulham an FA Cup replay is equally unwelcome as they prepare to face Juventus over two legs in the Europa League, with the small matter of a visit to Manchester United in between.

Hodgson’s squad has already been stretched by injuries to such regulars as Andrew Johnson, Clint Dempsey, Paul Konchesky and John Paintsil, and the absence of Danny Murphy from midfield on Saturday was noticeable as Jonathan Greening struggled to pick up the pace.

Fulham confirmed they are a power in the Europa League when they knocked out last season’s Uefa Cup winners, Shakhtar Donetsk, and reaching the FA Cup semi-finals would further enhance Hodgson’s standing as a manufacturer of silk purses from the ears of porcine females. Fulham, too, might already be there had Zamora, having finally escaped the stifling attentions of Sébastien Bassong, not dragged his shot wide five minutes from the end.

FA CupFulhamTottenham HotspurHarry RedknappRoy HodgsonDavid Laceyguardian.co.uk

Harry Redknapp’s derby day disaster does little to suggest Fab Four is about to become a Super Seven

Arsenal’s individual quality highlights the gulf in class between the big four and their challengers

Harry Redknapp’s hellish derby day featured dire defending by his side in a 3-0 loss, a row with a foul-mouthed Arsenal fan and a difference of opinion with his own captain over whether this Tottenham squad is as strong as Arsenal’s. Crossing the north London barbed wire is never fun for Spurs.

Robbie Keane had ventured the theory that the two feuding outfits are “on a par” and that the Tottenham bench “is probably a bit stronger” than Arsène Wenger’s ensemble of wonder boys. “I couldn’t really agree with him,” Redknapp said after Arsenal had extended their unbeaten Premier League run against Spurs to 20 matches. “He’s entitled to his opinion. They’ve got strength in depth in terms of fantastic young players waiting to burst into the team. They’re full of young talent at this club. That is where they are very, very strong. They keep producing great young players.”

This was not the plan. Redknapp came here to continue his assault on the league’s commanding heights and left praising the Arsenal academy and the philosophy that underpins it. It was an odd day all round. With his side 3-0 up at the end of a week in which Arsenal’s “kids” knocked Liverpool out of the Carling Cup, Wenger launched his suit jacket at his own seat, almost wrapping the face of his assistant, Pat Rice, in a veil of fine Italian wool.

“I threw my jacket because I was frustrated. I couldn’t communicate with the players because of the noise of the stadium – I’m not used to that,” the Arsenal manager joked. But it was Redknapp who had the best reason to chuck his wardrobe around. Spurs were marginally the better side until the last five minutes of the first period, when they conceded two embarrassing goals in 11 seconds of playing time.

“Forty-two minutes,” Redknapp announced, defining the period before Tottenham’s roof fell in. “Two sloppy goals we gave away – and turned the game upside down. I thought Arsenal were edgy, they were giving the ball away, the crowd was moaning at every mistake they made. I thought we were going to come in at half-time in great shape.”

The first was from a failure by Ledley King to intercept a cross by Bacary Sagna, which Robin van Persie reached first and converted. From the restart Wilson Palacios passed into a crowd of Arsenal players and Cesc Fábregas burst upfield, eluding Tom Huddlestone and King. For the third, after half-time, Heurelho Gomes failed to gather another Sagna cross and the ball rolled loose to Van Persie again.

The Premier League’s Fab Four are evolving into a Super Seven, the optimists say, and then a game like this makes it all seem wishful thinking. A full-strength Tottenham side remain a formidable force – Jermain Defoe, Luka Modric and Aaron Lennon were all missing here – but Harry Redknapp’s aspirants have now lost heavily to Manchester United, Chelsea and Arsenal in 11 league games.

“There is no gap between the [two] clubs, in my opinion,” Redknapp grumbled. “Arsenal let four goals in at Man City, does that make them a bad team? For 42 minutes I didn’t see anything that made me feel: ‘We’re out of our depth here, they’re playing wonderful football, they’re ripping us to pieces.’

“It was a horrendous second goal, and it made such a difference to the game. They walked off at half-time as if they’d played fantastically, with the crowd going wild – what a performance this has been – and we walked off with our heads on the floor.”

Redknapp lamented the absence of his game-changers. “You’re talking about three quick players, three of my very best players – special players who make the difference. Defoe was stupid and got sent off. Modric is still a fair way away. Lennon, with his ankle, is still a fair way away.” He also extended his private crusade against vile chanting, ordering an Arsenal steward to deal with an especially vocal gargoyle behind the Tottenham bench.

“Some guy was swearing and there were little kids sitting there. I didn’t swear in front of my kids. I just asked him if he could behave himself and act like a decent human being.”

Next on his hit list was the newspaper that reported him as saying the Premier League title cannot be won “with kids,” when all he had said was Chelsea and Manchester United possess a greater depth of experience than Wenger’s lot: “Course you can win things with kids. Man Utd proved it. Alan Hansen said you couldn’t and looked a fool. Nobody’s saying Arsenal can’t win the title. Of course they can. It’s wide open this year.”

For it to be so wide open that Spurs play a hand, Defoe must avoid red cards, King must defend, Gomes must smother crosses and Roman Pavlyuchenko must remember he is paid to move quicker than a Russian doll. Spurs are better than this aberrant defensive display suggests. But comparisons with Arsenal are best left unsaid.

Premier LeagueArsenalTottenham HotspurPaul Haywardguardian.co.uk